I Want to Buy Out My Spouse’s Interest in the Matrimonial Home
Photo by rawpixel.com on Freepik
I am hearing this more than ever. In separation and divorce, the desire to keep the family home—especially when children are involved—is completely understandable. You want to minimize disruption and maintain stability.
But then, the inevitable question from friends and family hits: "Can you even afford it?" This doubt can fuel the feeling of overwhelm, adding more stress to an already difficult time.
My role as your financial divorce specialist is to cut through that noise and doubt. My job is to determine if your desire is financially sustainable, guiding you through the critical questions with clarity and compassion to uncover practical and creative solutions.
The Financial Check
1. How is the Home's Value Determined?
- The Requirement: A professional, third-party appraisal is almost always required by a lender if you are going to take over the mortgage on your own. It is also the most accurate way to establish a fair market value for the separation agreement. Sometimes a realtor’s Opinion of Value or Comparative Market Analysis, or multiple opinions, are sufficient when the spouses agree on the opinion of the home’s value.
- The Formula: Fair market value minus outstanding mortgages/debts (secured by the home) equals home equity
- The Buyout Amount: Typically, the departing spouse's share is 50% of the home equity (value minus debt), but this amount is often adjusted as part of the overall "equalization payment".
Considering strategies for how equalization can be settled most effectively using a financial divorce specialist can be invaluable.
2. Can I Afford the New Mortgage on My Own?
This is the single biggest hurdle, and you could benefit from specialized expertise. Lenders look at your new financial picture—your income, your debts, and crucially, any child/spousal you pay or receive through a court order or a legally binding separation agreement.
Spousal or child support received is often treated as the recipient’s income by the lender thereby increasing their borrowing power, whereas support payments are treated as the payer’s monthly obligation reducing their future borrowing power.
The Spousal Buyout Mortgage Programs
These unique programs can be a game-changer, allowing the remaining spouse to refinance up to 95% of the home's value. This may be necessary to make the buyout possible without needing a large cash injection which may or may not be available.
As your financial divorce specialist, I always coordinate with a qualified mortgage broker who is experienced in separation and divorce. The broker is crucial, matching your unique financial needs with the appropriate lender programs to secure your financing. These programs may go beyond traditional bank financing solutions.
3. What about the Separation Agreement?
The Separation Agreement is the legal foundation of a spousal buyout (often, required by the lender) that formalizes:
- The agreed-upon buyout value for the determination of the equalization payment.
- The timeline for the buyout payment.
- The transfer of title and removal of the departing spouse from the original mortgage.
4. What Are the Tax and Financial Implications?
- Land Transfer Tax Exemption: In Ontario, transferring the title between separated spouses as part of a formal Separation Agreement exempts the transfer from Land Transfer Tax.
- Capital Gains: The buyout of a principal residence is generally tax-free due to the principal residence exemption but still requires reporting on your tax return in the year of transfer. If there are secondary properties like a vacation or rental property, this may require further consideration and expert tax advice.
- Other Costs: Don't forget appraisal fees, legal fees for the title transfer, and potential mortgage prepayment penalties for breaking the original mortgage.
The Emotional Challenges
So why do people fight so hard for the house, even when financially stretched?
- Stability for the children is usually the number one reason! Children thrive on routine. Staying in the home minimizes disruption to their schools, friends, community, etc. Can you put a price on that?
- For the spouse leaving, the buyout provides necessary equity for a fresh start. For the spouse staying perhaps they find comfort in retaining something familiar in an ocean of change.
Sometimes, the emotional cost of leaving is high, but the financial cost of staying can be higher. If the buyout forces you to be "house poor" (where most of your income goes to housing costs), it can lead to massive stress and hinder your long-term financial recovery. Always run a new, post-divorce budget first.
Get the Right Team Working for You
- Your Family Law Lawyer: To draft the legally binding Separation Agreement.
- CFDS/CPA: To strategically explore financially creative and viable options in the overall equalization/settlement.
- Mortgage Professional (Specializing in Separation): To pre-approve your capacity to carry the new mortgage and explore viable financing options.
Conclusion: Making Informed, Sustainable Decisions
The decision to buy out a spouse is complex, requiring a perfect marriage between emotions and financial due diligence. By addressing the common questions and facing the financial reality head-on, you can turn a difficult decision into your sustainable, independent future.
If you are navigating a separation and the matrimonial home is up for negotiation, contact me today to book a consultation. Let's explore how we can make it work for you.
This article is intended for educational purposes only and does not constitute personalized advice. The strategies and information discussed may not be suitable for your individual situation or may not be up-to-date and current. Please seek guidance from a licensed professional for advice specific to your circumstances.
Blog Contributors
Recent Posts
Subscribe to our newsletter
Want to stay up to date with our most recents articles?
Sign up below to receive emails whenever we have a new story!