Should You Withdraw Money From Your RRSP Before Retirement?

Should You Withdraw Money From Your RRSP Before Retirement?

Withdrawing from your RRSP before retirement can sometimes save you tax, particularly during a low-income year. But there are good reasons to leave the money invested too.

Most Canadians spend their working years trying to put money into a registered retirement savings plan (RRSP), so taking money out before retirement may seem counterintuitive. Why pay tax on a withdrawal today when you could leave the money invested and defer the tax until later?

In many cases, that is exactly what you should do. But an RRSP is not necessarily an account that you should avoid touching until you are required to take withdrawals. There are situations where an early withdrawal can make sense, particularly if your income is temporarily lower than usual.

The important question is whether you are better off paying tax on a withdrawal now or leaving the money invested and paying tax in the future.

Can You Withdraw From an RRSP Before Retirement?

You can generally withdraw money from a regular RRSP at any age. You do not need to stop working first or wait until age 65. Locked-in retirement accounts are different and generally have restrictions on withdrawals.

An RRSP provides a tax deduction when you contribute, subject to your available deduction limit, and investment income generally grows tax-deferred while it remains in the account. Withdrawals are generally taxable income, apart from exceptions such as qualifying withdrawals under the Home Buyers' Plan (HBP) or Lifelong Learning Plan (LLP).

When Does an Early RRSP Withdrawal Make Sense?

A year when your income drops significantly can be a good time to consider an RRSP withdrawal. You might have a gap between jobs or a year when your self-employment income is much lower than usual. A temporary drop in income could allow you to withdraw money at a lower marginal tax rate.

You do not necessarily need to spend the money either. If you have room in your tax-free savings account (TFSA), you could contribute some or all of the after-tax withdrawal to your TFSA.

But suppose you expect to retire in a few years and have even less taxable income then. It may be better to leave the money in your RRSP and withdraw it when your tax rate is lower.

Should You Withdraw From Your RRSP or TFSA First?

If you need money and have both an RRSP and TFSA, your TFSA may seem like the obvious account to use. After all, TFSA withdrawals are tax-free.

That may be the right choice. But if your taxable income is unusually low, withdrawing at least some money from your RRSP could make more sense over the long term.

An RRSP withdrawal increases your income for tax purposes and can affect income-tested government benefits. An ordinary RRSP withdrawal also does not give you the contribution room back.

With a TFSA, withdrawals do not add to your taxable income, and the amount withdrawn is added back to your contribution room at the beginning of the following calendar year. Future investment growth in the account is tax-free as well.

There is not a rule that says you should always withdraw from one account before the other. The tax you pay today matters, but so does the value of keeping money sheltered in each account.

How Much Tax Do You Pay When Withdrawing From an RRSP Early?

A common misconception about RRSP withdrawals is that the withholding tax is the actual tax you pay.

For Canadian residents outside Québec, financial institutions generally withhold 10% on lump-sum RRSP withdrawals up to $5,000, 20% on withdrawals over $5,000 and up to $15,000, and 30% on withdrawals over $15,000. Québec has different withholding requirements.

If you take a single $20,000 withdrawal outside Québec, your financial institution would generally withhold $6,000. That does not necessarily mean the withdrawal ultimately costs you $6,000 in tax.

The full withdrawal is included in your taxable income for the year. The tax already withheld is credited when you file your tax return, so you may owe more tax or get some of the withholding tax back.

The withholding rate should not determine whether you take an RRSP withdrawal. Your actual tax liability is what matters.

What Are the Disadvantages of Withdrawing From an RRSP Early?

The main drawback is that the money is no longer growing tax-deferred inside your RRSP. This matters more when you are younger because the money could have remained invested for many years.

You also do not get your RRSP contribution room back after an ordinary withdrawal. If you later decide you want to replace the money, you need enough unused contribution room to do so.

Spousal RRSP withdrawals require particular care. If the contributing spouse or common-law partner made contributions in the year of withdrawal or either of the previous two calendar years, some or all of the withdrawal may be attributed back to them for tax purposes.

The tax payable on this year's return is only part of the calculation. You also need to consider whether the withdrawal leaves you better off over time.

What if You Are Approaching Retirement?

The years around retirement can provide some of the best opportunities for planned RRSP withdrawals. Someone who retires at 60 may have relatively little taxable income before starting Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and Old Age Security (OAS) benefits. Drawing some money from their RRSP during those years could be more tax-efficient than preserving it for later.

Under current rules, you need to deal with your RRSP by the end of the year that you turn 71. You can withdraw the money, transfer it to a registered retirement income fund (RRIF), or use it to purchase an annuity.

If you have a large RRSP, waiting as long as possible to take withdrawals can mean paying more tax later. By then, you may also be receiving CPP and OAS, and larger withdrawals could push you into a higher tax bracket or cause some of your OAS to be clawed back.

I have written previously about reasons to consider early RRSP and RRIF withdrawals. Paying the least tax possible this year is not necessarily the same thing as paying the least tax over your lifetime.

Should You Withdraw From Your RRSP Before Retirement?

I would not recommend an RRSP withdrawal simply because you have had a low-income year. The decision should be based on your expected tax rates over time and how the withdrawal fits into your overall financial plan.

If you are approaching retirement, I would generally compare different withdrawal strategies using a retirement projection. The assumptions will never be perfect, but you can still get a reasonable sense of whether drawing down your RRSP earlier is likely to leave you better off.

At Objective Financial Partners, our fee-only, advice-only financial planners help Canadians make these decisions as part of their broader retirement planning. We do not manage investments or sell financial products, so clients can keep their existing investments while getting advice on how to draw on them in retirement.

If you are approaching retirement and trying to figure out when to draw from your RRSP, learn more about our retirement planning services or book a complimentary introductory call.

This article is intended for educational purposes only and does not constitute personalized advice. The strategies and information discussed may not be suitable for your individual situation or may not be up-to-date and current. Please seek guidance from a licensed professional for advice specific to your circumstances.

OFP_logo

Blog Contributors

Recent Posts

Subscribe to our newsletter

Want to stay up to date with our most recents articles?
Sign up below to receive emails whenever we have a new story!