1.855.691.8471 info@objectivefinancialpartners.com
Objective Financial Partners
  • Home
  • Our Firm
    • Testimonials
    • FAQ
    • Careers
  • Advice-Only Financial Planning
  • Executor/Probate/Estate Services
  • Tax Services
  • Other Services
    • Fee-Only, Advice-Only Financial Planning
    • Retirement Planning
    • Investment Planning
    • Estate Planning, Settlement, Probate, Executors
    • Canadian Expats
    • Planning for Seniors
    • Family Meetings
    • Financial Coaching Consultation
    • Personal Financial Audit
    • Fee-For-Service Insurance Consultation
    • Employee Financial Planning
    • Paraplanning and Outsourced Financial Planning
    • Services for Other Professionals
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Book a Call
Select Page

New Investment Approaches For Risk-Averse Canadians

by Jason Heath | Apr 21, 2021 | Jason Heath, MoneySense Magazine, News

The article “New Investment Approaches For Risk-Averse Canadians” was originally published on MoneySense on April 28, 2021.

Old-school investors may find the capital preservation techniques they have relied on in the past won’t work the same in the future.

Bonds have long been the solution for investors seeking capital preservation and reducing portfolio volatility. But falling interest rates have made it tough to earn a fixed income return while preserving capital.

The current weighted average yield to maturity for the FTSE Canada Universe Bond Index is about 1.72%. According to Morningstar’s 2019 Global Investor Experience Study, the asset-weighted median expense ratio for Canadian fixed income mutual funds was about 1.49% for investors receiving commission-based advice. For investors in fee-based accounts, it was 0.85%, plus management fees (often another 1%).

The result is that many fixed income investors are paying fees that are comparable to the expected return from an investment grade bond, implying basically no net return after fees (let alone after tax and inflation).

Interestingly, the aforementioned bond index returned 8.68% in 2020—and not many people in the investment community, nor bond investors themselves, would have expected an almost double-digit bond return last year. So, what was the reason for that surprise? Bonds and interest rates move in opposite directions, and interest rates fell due to the pandemic.

In much the same way bonds rose in 2020 as interest rates fell, if interest rates rise, bonds will fall. The Bank of Canada made an interest rate announcement on April 21, and as expected, kept interest rates steady. However, they have accelerated their timeline for inflation returning to their 2% target to the second half of 2022, meaning interest rate increases could come as early as next year if growth continues to heat up.

As interest rates rise, bonds fall. In fact, if interest rates rose by 1%, Canadian bonds – as measured by the FTSE Canada Universe Bond Index—would drop by about 8%.

So, what is a bond investor to do? Paying 1% to 2% to earn 1% to 2%, while taking on interest rate risk, is chancy. Guaranteed investment certificates (GICs) from credit unions or trust companies may provide higher returns for really conservative fixed-income investors. Higher-yielding, lower-credit quality bonds with higher coupon payments and shorter maturities may provide better returns in a rising-rate environment.

There are alternative investments, like real estate and infrastructure, but these tend to have higher fees and poor liquidity, and may be difficult for retail investors to access. These are all riskier investments than investment-grade bonds and may not provide the same benefits.

Bonds are not just meant for return. They are also meant for reducing volatility as stocks go up and down, so in that regard, should not be excluded from a portfolio for a conservative or moderate risk investor simply because interest rates are low.

Some income-seeking investors focus on value stocks of big, established companies that tend to pay higher dividends. Historically, value stocks have generally outperformed growth stocks. However, over the past 10 years, the S&P 500 Growth Index has outperformed the S&P 500 Value Index in eight out of 10 years, returning 16.2% versus 11.2% annualized (as of March 31, 2021). Investors who focused on value stocks over the past decade may have underperformed growth investors or total stock market investors as a result.

Rising interest rates may have a negative impact on dividend stocks, as investors who have opted for dividends over bond interest reduce their risk level once again.

Investors who have a long time horizon for their savings, with many years to retirement, should probably have a healthy exposure to stocks in their portfolio. For conservative investors who are in their 60s, one of the best options for preserving capital in retirement is not an investment at all. It is an application (two, in fact).

Applicants for the Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and Old Age Security (OAS) pensions often apply as early as possible. For CPP applicants, that is age 60 and for OAS applicants, age 65. There may be a fear of missing out mentality that leads to early pension application. Some seniors apply simply because the application comes in the mail.

Deferring CPP or OAS pensions leads to an increase in pension income. After age 65, the increased pension is 7.2% for OAS pensioners and 8.4% for CPP pensioners. Recipients who live into their 80s, especially those with a lower risk tolerance, may benefit from deferring their pensions and instead drawing down their low-risk, low-return investments early.

As interest rates have fallen, the expected future return from fixed-income investments has also fallen. The formula for CPP and OAS pensions has not changed and, therefore, the relative benefit of deferring CPP and OAS has increased.

The most important thing for an investor to understand is what rate of return they need to earn. What is the impact of earning a 2% return compared to 4% or 6%? If someone can retire at a reasonable age or fund their desired retirement objectives based on a low rate of return, maybe today’s low rates are just a nuisance. But if conservative investing may inhibit someone from achieving their financial goals, they may need to consider forgoing capital preservation for higher returns.

Jason Heath is a fee-only, advice-only Certified Financial Planner (CFP) at Objective Financial Partners Inc. in Toronto. He does not sell any financial products whatsoever.

Blog Contributors

Jason Heath
Nancy Grouni
Brenda Hiscock
Andrew Dobson

Recent Posts

  • Navigating Ontario Probate: Which Assets Require Probate and How to Minimize Costs March 22, 2023
  • What is the difference between an advice-only financial planner and a fee-based investment advisor? February 13, 2023
  • How to Apply for Probate of an Ontario Estate February 6, 2023
  • What is advice-only financial planning? January 6, 2023
  • Why It’s Time For Borrowers To Accept The New Normal Of Higher Rates And Plan Accordingly November 29, 2022
  • How Much To Take Out Of Your RRSP In Your 60s November 3, 2022
  • What Are The Tax Implications Of Selling U.S. Real Estate? October 31, 2022
  • Financial Gifts: What You Need To Know Before Giving Money Or Investments October 28, 2022
  • Can You Avoid Probate Taxes On TFSAs? October 28, 2022
  • How To Leave Money To Your Grandkids October 28, 2022

Subscribe to our newsletter

Want to stay up to date with our most recents articles?
Sign up below to recieve emails whenever we have a new story!

Contact Us

  • Please tell us about yourself and we will contact you within the next business day to schedule an introductory Zoom or phone meeting with one of our professionals.

    The purpose of this meeting is to understand your specific needs to determine if and how we can help. We then provide a quote for our services to be detailed in a written engagement letter that acts as our contract to you. Please note we cannot provide advice to you during this introductory meeting.

    We work with many self-directed DIY investors. That said, we cannot provide investment recommendations for the purchase or sale of specific securities, nor can other fee-only/advice-only financial planners in Canada who are not licensed to manage your investments.

    Please note our minimum consultation fee is $1,500 plus applicable sales tax. If you provide some information below and request it from us, we can provide a rough estimate on pricing prior to an introductory meeting.



    Ready to Book Your No Obligation Introductory Call?

    Book here for Financial Planning
    Book here if you are an EXPAT
    Book here if you have a CORPORATION
    Book here for Tax Services
    Book here for Executor/Probate/Estate Services


    To learn more about what we do, check out our services page and FAQ.
  • Choose any that apply.
  • Choose any that apply.
  • Privacy Policy

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Objective Financial Partners Inc.

675 Cochrane Drive
East Tower, 6th Floor
Markham, Ontario
L3R 0B8

  • Follow
  • Follow

T. 416.691.8471
Toll Free. 1.855.691.8471

Providing fee-only financial planning to clients in Toronto or worldwide via Zoom or Skype

Copyright © 2018 |Objective Financial Partners Inc. | All rights reserved.

We don't sell investments, so we're not going to tell you which stocks to buy and sell. However, we can build you a comprehensive and truly objective financial plan.

Please send email inquiries to info@objectivecfp.com