1.855.691.8471 info@objectivefinancialpartners.com
Objective Financial Partners
  • Home
  • Our Firm
    • Testimonials
    • FAQ
    • Careers
  • Advice-Only Financial Planning
  • Executor/Probate/Estate Services
  • Tax Services
  • Other Services
    • Fee-Only, Advice-Only Financial Planning
    • Retirement Planning
    • Investment Planning
    • Estate Planning, Settlement, Probate, Executors
    • Canadian Expats
    • Planning for Seniors
    • Family Meetings
    • Financial Coaching Consultation
    • Personal Financial Audit
    • Fee-For-Service Insurance Consultation
    • Employee Financial Wellness
    • Paraplanning and Outsourced Financial Planning
    • Services for Other Professionals
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Book a Call
Select Page

The Cost Of Socially Responsible Investing

by Jason Heath | Jul 22, 2020 | Jason Heath, MoneySense Magazine, News

The article “The Cost Of Socially Responsible Investing” was originally published on MoneySense on July 22, 2020.

Are there enough options available for Canadians who want to invest according to their values – and do you have to compromise on performance or fees to be a socially responsible investor?

 

Socially responsible investing (SRI) has seen increasing attention in recent years from investors who value the environmental, social, and corporate governance (ESG) factors of the investments they purchase.

Factors like the environmental conservation or impact of a company’s processes, and its employment equality, human rights and labour relations practices can be assessed. Companies affiliated with alcohol, gambling, tobacco, or weapons can be avoided. Religious principles may also require investments to be made based on certain principles, like Halal investing that complies with Islamic law.

But how well do SRIs perform compared with a broader portfolio? There are some studies that show outperformance as well as underperformance for socially responsible investors relative to other benchmarks. One of the broader studies was by Michael Schröder of the Leibniz Centre for European Economic Research. He looked at 29 global SRI indices and found that “SRI stock indices do not exhibit a different level of risk-adjusted return than conventional benchmarks.”

In Canada, the MSCI Canada ESG Leaders Index has outperformed the MSCI Canada Index since it was introduced in 2007 by about 2% per year.

Fees are another consideration for investors. SRI mutual funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) may have higher management expense ratios (MERs) than non-SRI funds. These funds may have lower assets under management, causing fixed fund management costs to be spread across fewer investors. At the end of 2019, the Investment Funds Institute of Canada (IFIC) reported 0.7% of mutual fund assets and 0.3% of ETF assets in Canada were considered “responsible investment funds.” There were a total of 69 mutual funds and 23 ETFs offered by 16 providers, comprising smaller fund companies like NEI Investments, as well as more established players like RBC offer ESG mutual funds, as well as many others. The big five ETF providers—BlackRock, BMO, Vanguard, Horizons and CI First Asset—all have ESG ETF options for investors.

The investment research firm Morningstar introduced a Morningstar Sustainability Rating in 2016. The tool can be used to help investors and advisors measure a mutual fund’s or ETF’s exposure to risks related to the ESG nature of its holdings, as well as to what degree the fund is committed to ESG principles.

Working with an investment advisor, you can collaboratively construct a portfolio that limits exposure to mutual funds, ETFs and stocks that are not in line with your values. Investors working with discretionary portfolio managers who use separately managed accounts may be able to exclude certain types of companies from their portfolio as part of their investment policy statement (IPS). Guided by the client’s statement, a manager will not add stocks of companies in certain industries or subject to certain criteria. This may prove more difficult for investors working with companies that use pooled funds where personalization of a portfolio is not an option (though pooled funds may not necessarily be invested in companies that are not socially responsible).

Robo-advisors like Wealthsimple, WealthBar, ModernAdvisor and Questwealth Portfolios have all introduced socially responsible, automated investment options for investors. Wealthsimple has even teamed up with fund company Mackenzie to recently introduce two socially responsible ETFs that trade on the Toronto Stock Exchange.

Investors should expect to see SRI and ESG investment options continue to expand. Fund companies, investment firms and even individual companies will probably also be more mindful of SRI/ESG criteria to make sure they can continue to be attractive to investors who place importance upon investing in line with their social values.

Jason Heath is a fee-only, advice-only Certified Financial Planner (CFP) at Objective Financial Partners Inc. in Toronto. He does not sell any financial products whatsoever.

Blog Contributors

Jason Heath
Nancy Grouni
Brenda Hiscock
Andrew Dobson

Recent Posts

  • How to develop a retirement plan July 18, 2023
  • Fee Only Financial Planning: The Benefits of Transparency and Personalization July 7, 2023
  • Determining Your Financial Independence Number and Sustainable Withdrawal Strategy June 2, 2023
  • Should This DIY Investor Go All In On This International ETF? May 29, 2023
  • These Are The Biggest Myths In Personal Finance — And They’ll Cost You If Followed Blindly May 26, 2023
  • Do Non-Residents Pay Tax On CPP? What If You Live In The U.S.? May 23, 2023
  • Should You Transfer Your DC Pension Plan To A Discount Brokerage? May 8, 2023
  • Market-Linked GICs: The Pros And Cons For Investors May 1, 2023
  • Are Mutual Fund Fees Tax Deductible? April 24, 2023
  • Can You Save Tax By Moving Into Your Rental Property? April 18, 2023

Subscribe to our newsletter

Want to stay up to date with our most recents articles?
Sign up below to receive emails whenever we have a new story!

Contact Us

  • Please tell us about yourself and we will contact you within the next business day to schedule an introductory Zoom or phone meeting with one of our professionals.

    The purpose of this meeting is to understand your specific needs to determine if and how we can help. We then provide a quote for our services to be detailed in a written engagement letter that acts as our contract to you. Please note we cannot provide advice to you during this introductory meeting.

    We work with many self-directed DIY investors. That said, we cannot provide investment recommendations for the purchase or sale of specific securities, nor can other fee-only/advice-only financial planners in Canada who are not licensed to manage your investments.

    Please note our minimum consultation fee is $1,500 plus applicable sales tax. If you provide some information below and request it from us, we can provide a rough estimate on pricing prior to an introductory meeting.



    Ready to Book Your No Obligation Introductory Call?

    Book here for Financial Planning
    Book here if you are an EXPAT
    Book here if you have a CORPORATION
    Book here for Tax Services
    Book here for Executor/Probate/Estate Services


    To learn more about what we do, check out our services page and FAQ.
  • Choose any that apply.
  • Choose any that apply.
  • Privacy Policy

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Objective Financial Partners Inc.

675 Cochrane Drive
East Tower, 6th Floor
Markham, Ontario
L3R 0B8

  • Follow
  • Follow

T. 416.691.8471
Toll Free. 1.855.691.8471

Providing fee-only financial planning to clients in Toronto or worldwide via Zoom or Skype

Copyright © 2018 |Objective Financial Partners Inc. | All rights reserved.

We don't sell investments, so we're not going to tell you which stocks to buy and sell. However, we can build you a comprehensive and truly objective financial plan.

Please send email inquiries to info@objectivecfp.com